Cleaning the air
In China, policy is driving the push to cleaner energy, but the setup in India makes the transition tougher
- China is already using policy to drive through the transition to a cleaner energy balance, but it needs to extend its efforts beyond the industrial Northeast
- Unlike China’s centralised approach, India’s fractured governmental structure will make the transition tougher, not least given the number of coal jobs in question
- The building of cleaner energy infrastructure, supply and distribution networks indicate compelling investment opportunities
China and India are making progress in tackling carbon dioxide emissions and local air pollution, creating opportunities for companies offering products and services to combat pollution
Demand from India and China for cleaner and more efficient factory equipment, public transport infrastructure and electric vehicle components is an opportunity for exporters in the region. Taiwanese, South Korean and Japanese companies have historically been early innovators in environmental markets and represent an opportunity to build regional partnerships insulated from potential global trade disputes.
How China is winning the war on air pollution
The Chinese government has repeatedly demonstrated that the ‘war on pollution’ goes far beyond rhetoric. For example, a pledge to cut carbon dioxide emissions per unit of GDP by 46% from 2005 levels by 2020 has been met three years ahead of schedule. In addition, local air quality has markedly improved in Beijing and 27 surrounding cities, with levels of toxic small particulates (“PM2.5”), dropping by 33.1% over a one-year period in the final quarter of 2017.
This progress has been achieved partly through the government taking drastic action to reduce coal use in 2017, which included switching off power stations and heavy industry fuelled by coal.
Alongside this, the transition to natural gas for heating, building public transport infrastructure and encouraging electric vehicle uptake represent longer-term solutions and investment opportunities.
With many factories in China’s Northeast shut down in 2017, industry output in other provinces increased, intensifying local pollution rather than reducing it. As well as ensuring that cutting emissions in the Northeast is executed in a sustainable manner, the next challenge for the Chinese government is to extend the growth of solutions to air pollution across other parts of the country.
China’s growing role in world affairs and its economic clout draw a lot of attention. However, the importance of India’s role in the transition to a more sustainable economy is difficult to overstate. Its population is set to exceed China’s by 2025, with energy demand predicted to double by 2040. Whatever policy decisions and consumer actions are made in India will have greater impact on worldwide emissions in the long term.
Opportunities in India’s energy transition
Currently, India’s power generation is dominated by coal, which produces around 75% of the country’s electricity. It is therefore unsurprising that 14 out of the 20 world’s most polluted cities are in India. As in China, an on-going transition to using natural gas for heating and power generation is a positive step towards a cleaner energy mix.
The transition in India may take longer as the country faces significant, and very different, challenges. For example, China has an extremely centralised power structure, and the government has demonstrated that it is prepared to make dramatic policy changes quickly.
In comparison, India is made up of a number of States and Unions, each with its own agenda and concerns; compromises must be forged and the subsidy of coal is popular in many areas due to the number of jobs provided by the coal industry.
The Indian government is aiming to increase the proportion of natural gas in the country’s energy mix from 6.5% to 15% by 2030. The huge deficits in energy infrastructure and the volume of gas that will need to be supplied to meet demand indicate a compelling investment opportunity if this target is to be met.
Furthermore, it is estimated that 240 million people in India have no reliable access to electricity, and so rely on polluting biomass stoves for indoor cooking and heating.
A successful transition to distributed electricity systems based on renewable energy could deliver heat and light in rural areas.
 China meets 2020 carbon target ahead of schedule: Xinhua; source: indiatimes.com (27 March 2018)
 PM2.5 in Beijing down by 54%, but nationwide air quality improvements slow as coal use increases; source: greenpeace.org (1 January 2018)
 India to outnumber China in population by 2025: US Census Bureau; source: indiatimes.org (30 December 2018)
 India Energy Outlook; source: iea.org (27 November 2015)
 India home to 14 of world’s 20 most polluted cities; source: asiancorrespondent.com (2 May 2018)
 Number of employees at Coal India Limited from 2002/2003 to 2016/2017; source: statista.com (31 March 2017)
 Indian state oil firms betting on natural gas as next big thing; source: reuters.com (17 November 2017)
 Living in the dark: 240 million Indians have no electricity; source: bloomberg.com (24 January 2017)
Investing in emerging markets, or specialised or restricted sectors is likely to be subject to a higher than average volatility due to a high degree of concentration, greater uncertainty because less information is available, there is less liquidity, or due to greater sensitivity to changes in market conditions (social, political and economic conditions).
Some emerging markets offer less security than the majority of international developed markets. For this reason, services for portfolio transactions, liquidation and conservation on behalf of funds invested in emerging markets may carry greater risk.